Critics say Haaland must leave Manchester City to fix a costly mistake

Erling Haaland is being urged to leave Manchester City, a suggestion that critics say would correct a costly error and restore the club’s fluid identity after years of relying on his singular goal‑scoring power.

CommentsSportopinionHarry Brent Senior Sports Writer05:30, 28 Aug 2026 View 3 ImagesErling Haaland might score goals galore - but is he really suited to Man City?(Image: Getty Images)

Why City signed Haaland

When Haaland arrived, Manchester City saw an otherworldly beast of a striker, a terrifying, laboratory‑designed goal‑golem who had already proven himself as a continent‑conquering force.

The Norwegian forward was praised for his ability to dominate the box, delivering a relentless stream of goals that seemed to guarantee silverware for the club.

The Alvarez alternative

When Julian Alvarez was allowed to quietly slip out the back door and catch a flight to Atletico Madrid two years ago, Manchester City fans might have felt a slight sting, but mostly they shrugged because they still had the Norse God of goalscoring.

Alvarez, the Argentine, is now linked to a £128million‑plus mega‑move to Arsenal and Barcelona, with separate reports of a £120m‑plus interest from the same clubs, highlighting his rising market value.

He possesses the low centre of gravity, explosive snap in his finish, and technical delicacy that marked Sergio Aguero’s natural heir, making him a versatile all‑action forward.

Potential impact of a sale

Critics argue that Haaland’s style limits City’s intricate possession game; he spends 89 minutes of a match loitering off the ball, contributing little to the build‑up that defines the club’s identity.

Selling Haaland could free Manchester City to re‑introduce a more fluid, multi‑directional attack, while the striker himself might thrive in a system that offers more movement and service.

The debate pits MAN CITY’s recruitment philosophy against the need for tactical cohesion, suggesting that parting ways with Haaland may ultimately benefit both the club and the Norwegian forward.