Zinedine Zidane already faces Pierre Ménès's first reservations

Zinédine Zidane, appointed new manager of the French national team, unveils this Friday his first squad for the next four Nations League matches, succeeding Didier Deschamps. His return to the bench is already drawing criticism, notably from former Canal+ analyst Pierre Ménès.
Pierre Ménès' reservations
Pierre Ménès, former Canal+ analyst, did not hide his doubts. He said: “Am I excited about Zidane? Not at all! I’m not a fan. Why? Because I’m not a fan of the man. The player was brilliant and the coach achieved great success by fitting into Carlo Ancelotti’s framework and managing the very high‑quality squad he had for three years without really making an extraordinary tactical revolution, nor even dominating opponents head‑to‑head. But still, he won three consecutive Champions Leagues.”
Ménès especially points to the five‑and‑a‑half‑year gap since Zidane left Real Madrid in 2021. He added: “Now, since then, he hasn’t done anything. It’s been five and a half years since he last coached, and I don’t see how he will invent a better goalkeeper than Maignan, how he will find a better right‑back than we have, how he will find better midfielders than the ones we have…”. He believes the national team does not operate like a club and that maintaining the current level would already be a good result.
Zidane’s record remains impressive: three consecutive Champions Leagues, a run of success at Real Madrid where he operated within Carlo Ancelotti’s framework. Despite these titles, Ménès notes the lack of a genuine tactical revolution and clear domination over opponents.
Riolo denounces the Bleus' indifference under Zidane despite Nations League qualification
The stakes for the Bleus
Nevertheless, the status of a five‑time world champion should make the group’s acceptance easier. Ménès said: “Yes, he will be a good manager, already because the players are crazy about him, they have immense respect for him. It will fit perfectly with Kylian Mbappé as also. But I think the French national team will have to step into Deschamps’ shoes…”. He therefore sees a potential Zidane‑Mbappé relationship as an asset.
Zidane succeeds Didier Deschamps with huge expectations. The next four Nations League matches provide a few weeks to impose his ideas.
Observers will scrutinize every decision. Media pressure is already very high.
November meeting of the Bleus under Zidane: points won and disappointed
Zidane’s past prestige contrasts with the immediate doubts. Time will be limited to convince the Bleus.