VAR controversy fuels City’s derby win at Old Trafford

Manchester City edged Manchester United 1‑0 at Old Trafford yesterday, with Erling Haaland finding the net in the 60th minute after a pinpoint Josko Gvardiol cross, securing Pep Guardiola’s side a famous derby triumph. The win came despite a red card for Phil Foden early in the second half, leaving City to play with ten men.

The first half unfolded with both sides probing for openings. Manchester United enjoyed spells of possession but were unable to break the disciplined City defence. A half‑hour in, a header from Enzo Maresca’s midfield was turned away, and the half ended goalless.

Second‑half drama

What unfolded in the 60th minute changed the match. Haaland, who had been denied earlier, coolly slotted home a Josko Gvardiol cross at the back post, giving City the lead.

Enzo Fernandez had attempted to head the same cross and was judged offside, prompting a VAR review. Officials ruled that Fernandez was not influencing play and confirmed Haaland’s goal, although later analysis suggested the decision was erroneous.

VAR admission and aftermath

City held on to win 1‑0, sealing the 199th Manchester derby at Old Trafford. Ref Pro later admitted an error in the VAR ruling and issued an apology to United, confirming that Haaland’s winner should not have stood.

The controversy echoed a 2023 derby when United’s equaliser was awarded despite Rashford’s off‑side involvement, a decision that sparked similar debate. Critics have labelled the technology a ‘circus’, arguing that yesterday’s call adds to a growing list of high‑profile VAR howlers at Old Trafford.