VAR concedes mistake in Erling Haaland’s Manchester derby decision

Manchester City’s 1‑0 win at Old Trafford on Sunday has been clouded by a VAR admission that the decisive goal should not have stood, meaning the match‑winning strike by Erling Haaland now sits under a cloud of controversy and raises questions about the technology’s reliability in the Premier League.

Goal and red card

The hour‑mark strike from Erling Haaland gave the ten‑man visitors a 1‑0 victory at Trafford after Phil Foden was sent off early in the first half. City, reduced to ten men, held on to the lead despite Manchester United’s pressure, securing three points in the Premier League clash.

VAR review and technology

Haaland was initially flagged offside when he tucked in Josko Gvardiol’s deflected cross from the left wing, but VAR intervened after a lengthy check and ruled him onside, aligning his position with Patrick Dorgu’s foot. The Premier League’s semi‑automated off‑side system later confirmed Haaland was behind Dorgu, overturning the on‑field call.

Enzo Fernandez was also in an off‑side position and appeared to interfere with play, yet the Premier League Match Centre noted he did not touch the ball, allowing the goal to stand. Lisandro Martinez branded the decision an “injustice”, arguing Fernandez’s presence impacted the play.

Hours after the match, Pro Ref admitted an “error of judgement”. A spokesperson said the VAR should have recommended an on‑field review of Fernandez’s position and that the on‑field decision was incorrectly deemed on‑side. Pro Ref has contacted Manchester United to acknowledge the mistake and a review will take place.

Manchester United manager Michael Carrick expressed fury, calling the explanation “staggering” and worrying about the interpretation of the laws. He said the decision does not change the season but has a major impact on the game.

Haaland’s ninth league goal against United makes him the top scorer in Manchester derbies in the Premier League. The Man derby record now sits alongside the controversy surrounding the VAR process.