Milan’s Mike Maignan faces captaincy doubts despite new contract

On a crisp Milan morning, the news that Mike Maignan, the former Parisien, signed a new deal in June seemed to settle his future at AC Milan. Yet, on the other side of the Alpes, his captaincy remains under fire, with former defender Alessandro Costacurta openly questioning the Frenchman's suitability.
Costacurta questions Maignan’s captaincy
Alessandro Costacurta, the former Italy international, told Sky Italia in June: “Je ne pense pas que Maignan soit le bon capitaine pour cette équipe.” He added that a side arriving ten times late to the kick‑off and receiving reprimands “is not well led”, suggesting the armband belong to Gabbia or Modric instead.
Ruben Amorim, the Portuguese coach, rejected those claims. Speaking to Les médias after L’Équipe published its Friday report, he said, “I have spoken with Mike. I feel he is involved with our club. He is a leader, and you can sense it at every training.”
According to the same L’Équipe piece, the club’s hierarchy insists Maignan’s role as captain has never truly been in jeopardy. The management, echoing Amorim, affirmed that they want to keep him at San Siro, describing him as “very, very important for us.”
The debate highlights how leadership at elite clubs can be contested off the pitch, with legends and media shaping narratives even after a player secures his future. For Milan, the episode underscores the delicate balance between on‑field performance and off‑field authority.