Manchester United's early slump forces Carrick to act before Fulham
Manchester United have won only one of their first four league matches and were dumped out of the League Cup at home by Brighton on Wednesday. The defeat was described as embarrassing and has set off alarm bells at Old Trafford. With the side still in the early stages of the season, manager Michael Carrick faces intense pressure ahead of Sunday’s trip to Fulham.
Attacking numbers look healthy
Despite the poor results, United have recorded the most touches inside the opponents’ box in the first four weeks of the campaign. They also boast the second‑highest expected goals total at 8.3, having actually scored seven, rank third for accurate crosses per match, fourth for chances created and third for accurate passes per match. These statistics suggest the team is creating opportunities, but the figures evaporate once the ball reaches the final third.
Finishing under pressure
In the final third, United have struggled to convert. Bryan Mbeumo, Marcus Rashford, Matheus Cunha and Bruno Fernandes have all over‑thought their finishes and missed clear chances. The lack of clinical finishing means the side relies heavily on experienced finishers to step up, a role that has not been fulfilled so far.
Defence lacks bite
United have made the fewest clearances in the Premier League and rank sixteenth for possession won in the final third per match. They sit third for overall possession but fourteenth for total distance covered, indicating a lack of physical intensity. Defenders appear tired and confused, often failing to defend as a cohesive unit.
Manchester United weigh McTominay return as Carrick battles early woes
Pressing and cohesion
Harry Maguire and Lisandro Martinez are capable of winning aerial and ground duels, yet gaps alongside and in front of them leave the central defenders exposed. The team needs to press higher together and spring counters, but forwards press while midfielders lag behind and defenders drop off, creating a disjointed shape.
Midfield balance
Carlos Baleba’s return to fitness after the international break should add stability, but United still require a destroyer to partner either Kobbie Mainoo or Youri Tielemans. Mainoo and Tielemans cannot occupy the same role; last season Casemiro provided the ball‑winning edge that Mainoo exploited. New signing Andrey Santos has struggled to adapt as a holding midfielder, and Baleba alone will not solve all the issues.
Transfer window regrets
The recent Manchester derby highlighted the impact of missing Elliot Anderson this summer; his energy, reading of the game and ability to break up play are qualities United now lack. The club appears to have placed all its hopes in Baleba, and it would be hyperbole to claim the season does not depend on him hitting the ground running.
Looking ahead
With Fulham awaiting on Sunday, Carrick must find a way to tighten the defence, improve finishing and restore cohesion. The coming weeks will test whether United can translate their promising possession statistics into tangible results.