Manchester United contest the derby goal after a VAR error
Manchester City's decisive goal, scored in the 57th minute, was allowed despite an off‑side position by Enzo Fernandez, an error that the Pro Ref admitted after the final whistle, leaving Manchester United with a feeling of regret.
Line‑ups and expectations before the derby
Two Red Devils were on the pitch, with Senne Lammens and Youri Tielemans in the starting line‑up for Manchester United. The Red Devils entered the match with increased confidence, for United, after intensive preparation. Manchester United displayed a solid attacking line from the first moments.
Manchester City dominated the first half, playing ten against eleven for seventy minutes before the match turned. Midfielder Phil Foden was sent off early in the game, leaving the Red Devils under constant pressure. City controlled the midfield, creating several dangerous chances.
VAR error that changed the result
Manchester City's only goal, scored in the 57th minute, was validated despite Enzo Fernandez's off‑side position, which should have prompted the VAR to intervene. According to the Pro Ref, the referee should have been called to the screen, but that did not happen, and the Ref upheld the goal. Erling Haaland was not involved in the play, his position posed no issue. This decision fueled the debate over the effectiveness of the video‑review system.
A few hours after the final whistle, the Pro Ref acknowledged the judgment error and offered an apology to Manchester United. The body said it would examine why the VAR did not intervene, to prevent such situations from recurring. The planned investigation will clarify the video‑review procedures.
If the goal had been disallowed, the score would have remained 0‑0 at that point in the match, completely changing the derby scenario. This cancellation would also have prevented Manchester United's defeat by the smallest margin. A draw would have given United an extra point in the league race.
Manchester United therefore has reason to be frustrated, the Red Devils feeling a deep sense of regret. For United, the belated acknowledgment of the error does not compensate for the loss of the crucial point. Supporters expressed their displeasure on social media, demanding corrective measures.
The final result, a 0‑1 defeat for Manchester United against Manchester City, leaves the Red Devils with a narrow but decisive setback. This loss keeps United in the race, though it does not provide immediate relief. The derby remains one of the most anticipated clashes of the season.