Leonardo’s debut goal sparks hope, but doubts linger at Ajax

Marcos Leonardo celebrated his first Ajax shirt goal with a decisive header against FC Sion in a 2‑4 victory last Thursday, yet critics continue to question whether the Brazilian striker is physically ready for the Dutch side’s demands.

Goal and immediate criticism

The header marked Leonardo’s inaugural strike for Ajax, offering a bright moment for the recent Ajax purchase.

Despite the celebration, pundles argue that the forward is “too fat,” keeping doubts about his suitability alive.

Maduro’s deeper analysis and alternatives

On the talk‑show Kale & Kokkie, former Ajax player and analyst Maduro acknowledged the criticism as justified, linking it to heightened expectations surrounding the new signing.

He added, “A lot has been said about his fitness. From the outside they say he is too fat. But he is not too fat.”

Dutch women’s sides stumble in Europe as Ajax and PSV lose

Maduro further argued that Leonardo “lacks match content” and questioned whether he can sustain Ajax’s high‑intensity training, which relies heavily on short‑range positional games.

He noted that Ajax’s sessions are more intense than what the player may have experienced in previous clubs, emphasizing the need for technical skill.

Referencing Josip Sutalo’s early struggles at Ajax, Maduro highlighted the importance of a stable family situation for South American, Spanish and Italian players, asking whether Leonardo’s children, home and spouse are settled.

Maduro also suggested that Tolu Arokodare could take over the role, praising the younger forward’s strength and suitability against weaker opponents, noting that a single Tolu in the starting sixteen already occupies two defensive positions.

Finally, he described Leonardo as a striker who “must be launched,” making runs without yet receiving well‑timed service, a profile that differs from the more direct style of Tolu.

The contrast between Leonardo’s early goal and the persistent doubts expressed by critics and analysts underscores the uncertainty surrounding his future impact at Ajax, while the club continues to weigh alternative options.