Bruno Fernandes slams Carrick’s tactics after United’s 4‑1 thrashing, sparks coaching change rumours

Manchester United captain Bruno Fernandes has openly questioned Michael Carrick’s tactical decisions following the Red Devils’ 4‑1 defeat to Como in northern Italy, intensifying speculation that the manager’s tenure could be under threat. Fernandes’ remarks, delivered in a post‑match interview with, marked the first time a senior player has publicly challenged Carrick’s approach this season, just 11 games into his permanent spell.

United’s loss to the Serie B side was their worst in the Premier League campaign, with the team struggling to retain possession and being exposed by Como’s high‑pressing game. The defeat left United with only two league wins so far, against Ipswich and Sabah, and placed them in a precarious position ahead of a crucial home clash with Bournemouth.

“Everyone at the club must understand that it’s no longer the same,” Fernandes said. “We’re no longer living in the past and we must look to the future. We have to create something different in the present.” The midfielder added that the squad’s focus on past glories was hampering progress and that “the most important thing is that we’re not performing as we expect.”

Carrick under mounting pressure as United weigh his future and Fernandes' captaincy

Fernandes also singled out Carrick’s decision to replace him with Joshua Zirkzee at halftime, calling it “a very difficult match for us” and suggesting the substitution did little to alter the tactical battle. “It was almost impossible to play with the ball, we weren’t close enough to maintain possession,” he explained, adding that Como’s man‑to‑man pressing exposed United’s inability to control the midfield.

Behind the scenes, United’s director of recruitment Christopher Vivell is reportedly advocating for a swift appointment of Julian Nagelsmann should Carrick be dismissed, underscoring the growing impatience within the hierarchy. The club, however, has not signalled any immediate intention to part ways with Carrick, who was handed a permanent contract only months ago.

Bruno Fernandes' home robbed while United play in Italy

The captain’s candid interview has added pressure on Carrick ahead of United’s next Premier League fixture against Bournemouth on Sunday, a match many view as a potential turning point. A positive result could buy Carrick more time, while another setback may accelerate calls for a managerial change.

Fans and pundits alike have reacted strongly to Fernandes’ comments, with social media buzzing about the apparent split within the dressing room. While some praise the captain’s honesty, others warn that public criticism could further destabilise a squad already struggling for form.